7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (2023)

byAndré Radford


This article containsaffiliate linkswhich allows us to earn a small commission on purchases made through the links (at no additional cost to you). We appreciate your support!

Every aspiring whiskey connoisseur should have at least one bottle of American rye whiskey in their pantry. The best American rye whiskeys are naturally spicier than their non-rye whiskey cousins, contributing flavors of black pepper, nutmeg, cinnamon, and even smoke.

Index

  1. What is rye whiskey?
  2. whisky normal vs whisky de centeno
  3. The 7 Best American Rye Whiskeys
    • 1. Whisky de centeno Rittenhouse
    • 2. Look for Balcones Texas Rye 100
    • 3. Few rye whiskey
    • 4. Whiskey de centeno Jim Beam
    • 5. Pikesville 6 Year Old Rye Whiskey
    • 6. Sagamore Double Oak Rye Whiskey
    • 7. WhistlePig 12 Year Old Rye Whiskey
  4. Andrew's Best Choice
    • WhistlePig 12 Year Old Rye Whiskey
  5. conclusion
  6. Other reading

What is rye whiskey?

A whiskey must meet a list ofstringent government requirementsbe labeled as rye whiskey. The grain mix for the wort must contain a minimum of 51% rye (a type of grass) produced at a maximum of 80% ABV. Finally, it must be stored at no more than 62.5% ABV in charred oak barrels or casks.

whisky normal vs whisky de centeno

Regular whiskey can be made with corn, wheat, barley, or a combination of grains. This allows the distillery to have a wide variety of flavors and aromas. However, rye whiskey must be made from at least 51% rye (a type of grass), which gives rye whiskey its uniquely spicy flavor profile.

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (1)

The 7 Best American Rye Whiskeys

The best American rye whiskeys are bursting with the spicy flavors of pepper, nutmeg, cinnamon and a hint of smokiness. Here are 7 to consider.

1. Whisky de centeno Rittenhouse

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (2)

Overview

  • Distiller:Hill of Heaven Distillery
  • ABV:50% (100 tests)
  • Country:Kentucky, United States
  • Heart:Mahogany

Analysis

Founded in 1935 by the Shapira family,Hill of Heaven DistilleryHe's had his fair share of bad luck over the years. On November 7, 1996, the distillery was struck by lightning and burned down, destroying property and 92,000 barrels of whiskey. Since then the distillery has moved on and has continued to distill its famous rye whiskey.

A wort made up of 52% rye, 35% corn and 13% malt can ferment for up to five days (fuente🇧🇷 The wort is then passed through 70 foot tall beer columns before being distilled a second time. The rye whiskey is then placed in charred American oak barrels and matured for four years.

not nose

A bouquet of sweet caramel, peach and white pepper.

not palate

Blackberry and vanilla with a hint of nutmeg leading to a smooth, fruity finish with a hint of maple spice and cocoa. I liked the lingering ending.

best served

Rittenhouse Rye whiskey is best enjoyed on the rocks or in a flavorfulcoctel manhattan.

(Video) Top 20 Most Popular Whisk(e)ys in America (according to U.S. sales)

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

2. Look for Balcones Texas Rye 100

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (3)

Overview

  • Distiller:balconies
  • ABV:50% (100 tests)
  • Country:Texas, United States
  • Heart:Dark brown

Analysis

distillery balconieswas launched in a small weld shop in Waco, Texas in 2008. They imported copper stills from Portugal and turned the small weld shop into a mini distillery. In 2009, Balcones distilled its first batch of rye whiskey.

Balcones uses a minimum of four types of rye for its must; Elbon, chocolate, roasted and crystal rye. The must is distilled in copper stills and the whiskey is vatted. The whiskey is aged for 18 months before being bottled at 100 proof.

not nose

Dark chocolate, caramel and black pepper on the nose.

not palate

Rich chocolate and caramel flavor, with subtle hints of oak, coffee and pepper on the mid palate. The finish is smooth with hints of chocolate and nuts.

best served

Balcones Texas Rye 100 Whiskey is best enjoyed neat or as a traditional chocolate.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

3. Few rye whiskey

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (4)

Overview

  • Distiller:FEW spirits
  • ABV:46.5% (93 tests)
  • Country:Illinois, United States
  • Heart:Amber

Analysis

Started by Paul Hletko in 1933 at a breakers shop in Evanston, Illinois,SOMEhe decided to make rye whiskey that would rival Kentucky whiskeys. The distillery is named after temperance activist Frances Elizabeth Willard.

FEW Rye Whiskey is made from a blend of 70% rye, 20% corn, and 10% malted barley. This wort is similar to the production of the Saison beer and is distilled and poured into new charred oak barrels, aged for a minimum of one year before bottling.

not nose

Sweet vanilla, cinnamon and oak on the nose with hints of orange zest and black pepper.

(Video) Maryland Heritage Series Rye Whiskeys! Mount Vernon, Sherbrook & Sherwood reviewed + history!

not palate

Spiced honey, smoky rye grains and oak on the palate with a hint of black pepper.

best served

FEW Rye whiskey is best served neat on the rocks, or consider trying it in a tastyBOLD FEWcocktail.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

4. Whiskey de centeno Jim Beam

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (5)

Overview

  • Distiller:haz you guys
  • ABV:40% (80 tests)
  • Country:Kentucky, United States
  • Heart:dark amber

Analysis

Made with an old family recipe,haz you guyshe decided to bring back a pre-prohibition flavor with his rye whiskey. The whiskey met the exacting standards that have governed whiskey production for nearly 200 years.

Jim Beam Rye Whiskey is made from a mash containing a minimum of 51% rye and barley. The mash bead is allowed to ferment into a "distilled ale" before being distilled through a 65 foot column. The whiskey is aged in new charred oak barrels for four years.

Look at my article,7 whiskies Jim Beam elaborados con Kentucky Magic, if you like to know the brand in depth.

not nose

Aromas of rich fruit, orange zest and black pepper.

not palate

A distinctive vanilla sweetness on the palate, spiced with black pepper, rye grains, oak and a subtle hint of citrus zest.

best served

Personally, I prefer my Jim Beam Rye whiskey neat, but you can try it in a Rye Orleans or Old Fashioned cocktail.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

5. Pikesville 6 Year Old Rye Whiskey

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (6)
(Video) Super Simple, Super Tasty Irish Hot Whiskey Recipe

Overview

  • Distiller:Hill of Heaven Distillery
  • ABV:55% (110 tests)
  • Country:Kentucky, United States
  • Heart:Mahogany

Analysis

Pikesville rye whiskey was first produced in Maryland in the pre-Prohibition era. DespitePikesvillestarted distilling after prohibition ended, he moved to Kentucky, making whiskey the traditional way.

A wort made up of 51% rye, 39% corn and 13% malted barley is fermented before passing through a 21 meter high column. The rye whiskey is then placed in virgin American white oak barrels, aged for six years, and bottled at 110 proof.

not nose

Caramel, cocoa, smoked in oak with a hint of pepper.

not palate

Bittersweet dark chocolate, honey and cloves with earthy grains on the mid palate. A smooth vanilla finish with a hint of lingering spice.

best served

Pikesville 6 Year Old Rye Whiskey can be enjoyed neat on the rocks or in an Old Pal cocktail.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

6. Sagamore Double Oak Rye Whiskey

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (7)

Overview

  • Distiller:spirit of sagamore
  • ABV:48.3% (96.6 tests)
  • Country:Maryland, United States
  • Heart:rich amber

Analysis

spirit of sagamoreis proud to use only Maryland-grown rye for its whiskeys. They have built a great relationship with the local farmers who supply all the ingredients necessary to produce their award winning rye whisky.

A wort consisting of 95% rye and 5% barley is fermented and distilled in a 40 foot tall copper "alembic" column. The distillate is placed in new charred American oak barrels for 4 to 5 years, then placed in toasted wooden barrels for another 18 months.

not nose

Cinnamon, vanilla and dried fruit on the nose with a hint of fresh nuts.

not palate

Caramel and hazelnut on the palate with notes of cinnamon, walnuts and burnt coconut.

best served

Sagamore Double Oak Rye Whiskey is best served neat or as aCidra Sagamore, with sweet apple cider, lime juice, simple syrup and a cinnamon stick garnished with an apple slice.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

7. WhistlePig 12 Year Old Rye Whiskey

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (8)

Overview

  • Distiller:Distillaria Whistle Pig
  • ABV:43% (86 tests)
  • Country:Vermont, United States
  • Heart:rich amber

Analysis

In 2007, a group of rye whiskey enthusiasts bought a dairy farm in Vermont and turned it into a distillery. Master Distiller Dave Pickerell joined the team onwhistlepig, and together they created a rye whiskey with a truly unique taste.

Rye Whiskey is made from a blend of 79% rye, 15% malted rye and 6% barley. The must is distilled in a copper still and aged in three different barrels. 63% of the distilled whiskey is placed in Madeira barrels, 30% in Sauternes barrels and 7% in Port barrels and is aged for 12 years.

Before bottling, the three whiskeys are perfectly blended to produce WhistlePig 12-Year Old World Rye Whiskey.

not nose

Nuts, caramel and sweet vanilla on the nose.

not palate

Ripe apricot, dark raisins, plum and honey on the palate with delicate spicy notes. The finish is ultra-smooth and I love the rich fruit, dark chocolate, and vanilla.

best served

WhistlePig 12 Year Old World Rye Whiskey is best served neat, and may be added with awater splashto further open the scent. Also try a rye version ofdirty shirleycocktail garnished with a cherry.

prices and information

You can check the latest prices, product information and order online.

(Video) Is FLAVORED Whiskey Actually Bad? (or are we just too afraid to admit the deliciousness...)
7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (9)

Andrew's Best Choice

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (10)

WhistlePig 12 Year Old Rye Whiskey

my favorite option isWhistlepig 12 years old 'Old World Rye'🇧🇷 The rich fruit and honey notes are intensified by the delicate spice of rye. Enjoy it neat on the rocks for the ultimate rye whiskey experience.

conclusion

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (11)

Ingrid and I have just returned from a research trip to Belgium, where we sampled whiskeys from around the world, including the classic American rye (more on this trip in future articles!).

American rye whiskey must comply withstrict regulationsto be considered a rye whiskey. These whiskeys come from a long line of traditions dating back to the prohibition era. American rye whiskey is quickly becoming more popular as more distilleries experiment with its incredible flavor profile.

Be sure to check out our articles on9 excellent Irish whiskeysmi9 Japanese Whiskeys for Beginners.

7 Spicy Rich American Rye Whiskeys | drinks nerd (12)

Other reading

Here are some additional articles from The Drinks Geek blog. We write articles on many fascinating areas of drinks, including different brands, types of drinks, cocktail recipes, and much more.

(Video) THE SEXTON | Irish Single Malt Whiskey Review

We offer a worldwide beverage analysis service to help our readers in all countries make informed decisions about purchasing beverages for events, parties, gifts, or simply to enjoy at home.

Our primary audience is from the US, UK, Canada, Australia and Europe, although we have readers from as far away as Mauritius!

FAQs

What is the highest rated rye whiskey? ›

What is the highest rated rye whiskey? There are a few rye whiskeys that consistently rank highly among critics and experts. Some of the highest-rated rye whiskeys include Sazerac 18-Year Rye, Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye, High West Double Rye!, and WhistlePig 10 Year.

Why rye whiskey is the best? ›

Rye brings spicy notes to the palate that are not always as present in other types of whiskey like bourbon. Think baking spices like nutmeg, cinnamon, and pepper, which make this whiskey a classic choice to use in cocktails that have a bit of sweetness to counterbalance the character of the rye.

What whiskey does MGP make? ›

One primary product of MGP Indiana is a straight rye whiskey with a 95% rye mash bill, which is bottled under various brand names, including Angel's Envy, Bulleit Rye, Filibuster, George Dickel Rye, James E. Pepper, Smooth Ambler, and Templeton Rye.

What does MGP stand for in bourbon? ›

In a world of small-batch whiskeys and craft production, the increased popularity of Midwest Grain Product, or "MGP bourbon" may shock some bourbon enthusiasts.

What is a spicy rye whiskey? ›

Rye is known for its peppery bite, a spicy splash of flavor that washes over the palate with every sip. Some are more aggressive than others, of course, but with rye grain making up the majority of its malt bill, you're bound to pick up at least a touch of that signature sting.

Is rye better than bourbon? ›

Rye: Rye has a spicier taste. Many feel that it has notes of grass and pepper, as well as oak, smoke, and fruit. Bourbon: Most will agree that bourbon has a sweeter taste than rye with notes of vanilla, caramel, and oak. Bourbon has an overall lighter and smoother taste than rye.

What does rye whiskey say about you? ›

Rye whiskey drinkers tend to be a discerning and hip bunch. You love to stay ahead of the curve and on top of the latest trends.

Is rye whiskey a healthy drink? ›

Adding rye into your diet regularly can help those who suffer from high blood pressure. It is the combination of the fibers, vitamins and minerals that all play a role in lowering the blood pressure. In return, this leads to a reduced risk of heart attack, stroke and blood clots.

Is rye whiskey good for your stomach? ›

Whiskey is a Digestion Aid

The high proof whiskey stimulates the stomach's enzymes, which help to break down food. This benefit makes whiskey an excellent part of your next happy hour.

Is Angel's Envy MGP? ›

Angel's Envy, whose rum barrel-finished rye comes from MGP, is one of the best known practitioners of extra-aging.

Does MGP bottle their own bourbon? ›

You have most likely enjoyed MGP whiskey at some point, even if you were not aware you were doing so. That's because this Lawrenceburg, Indiana distillery-factory makes bourbon, rye and other spirits that many other brands purchase and bottle under their own names.

Is bulleit still MGP? ›

Bulleit bourbon is famous for its rye whiskey, made from a whopping 95% rye and 5% malted barley — which comes from MGP. This whiskey brand has one of the industry's most iconic bourbon and rye whiskies.

What is the best tasting smoothest whiskey? ›

The Woodford Reserve Kentucky straight bourbon is one of the smoothest whiskey on the market. It's a unique combination of over 200 flavor notes, including wood, fruit, bold grain, and sweet aromatics. The finish of this bourbon is silky smooth with a creamy aftertaste.

What is the highest rated whiskey in the world? ›

The Glenmorangie Signet is considered the best whisky in the world, thanks to its use of high roast chocolate malt barley with a blend of Glenmorangie's rarest whiskies matured in bespoke casks.

What is the smoothest top shelf whiskey? ›

Laphroaig is the smoothest top-shelf whiskey. The Scotch whisky has a smooth-smoky taste that is not overpowering and complements other flavor notes of the spirit well. Moreso, blended scotch is more approachable and easy to drink than other types of whiskey.

Videos

1. Blind $5,000 Whisky Taste Test w/ The World's FANCIEST Man
(Whiskey Tribe)
2. 9 GREAT Whiskeys You've Never Heard Of... (probably)
(Whiskey Tribe)
3. BOOKER'S RYE
(Whisky In The 6)
4. The Rattlesnake - A Cocktail Recipe with some Bite!
(The Whiskey Nerd)
5. Mash and Drum LIVE! Tis the season for NEW RYE'S! + BLENDAGEDDON American Blends Week 6!
(The Mash and Drum)
6. Edd's Top Ten Ryes
(The Rotgut Review)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated: 03/10/2023

Views: 6516

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.